Fanficcing With Claude: A Curious Case, Chapter 2 (Elizabeth)

The Curious Case of the Kentish Clergyman, Chapter 2. Narrated by Elizabeth Bennet Darcy.

"And what," said Charlotte Lucas, appearing at my elbow with two cups of punch before the first dance had ended, "is a Mr. Collins? Maria swears your mother has one staying at Longbourn, and my mother is in agonies for want of facts."

"He is my father's cousin," I said, "and heir to Longbourn after him, the estate being entailed away from us girls. He has lately taken orders, and got a living in Kent from a great lady called Lady Catherine de Bourgh, of whom you are to hear a very great deal whether you wish it or not. He has come to look us over."

"To look you over."

"He calls it an olive branch. I believe he means to choose a wife from among us, and feels that the entail entitles him to one, the way it entitles him to the silver."

"That is not the worst arrangement a woman might make."

"You have not heard him on the subject of his patroness."

"I have heard worse men on smaller subjects," said Charlotte, "and known them make easy enough husbands once the courting was done. A clergyman with a living, and an estate to come, is not nothing, Eliza, whatever he sounds like across a supper table."

This was an old argument between us, and I had never once won it, so I directed her attention to the man himself instead.

The assembly rooms at Meryton were never large, and that night they were smaller still, for half the county had crowded in to be disappointed by them. I have been in finer rooms since, and colder ones, and one or two I would give a good deal never to have entered at all; but I remember that room as it stood that evening, low-ceilinged and over-warm and loud, the whole neighbourhood having got hold of a single piece of news and resolved to make a winter of it. The news was that Mr. Bingley had taken Netherfield, was young, was unmarried, and had five thousand a year. My mother had it by heart within an hour of its arrival — five thousand, Mr. Bennet, and very likely more — and had recited it across the breakfast table every morning for a fortnight. My father received these communications as he received most of her communications, from behind a book; and he received the assembly itself by staying home with it.

Mr. Collins had attached himself that evening to Jane, the eldest and the handsomest of us, the entail having furnished him a choice he meant to make from the top down. Charlotte and I drifted near enough to hear him at the work. He had arrived at the chimney-piece in the drawing-room at Rosings Park.

"—eight hundred pounds, Miss Bennet. I have the figure from her ladyship herself. Eight hundred pounds, for the chimney-piece alone."

"It must be very fine," said Jane.

"It is beyond anything I could convey. I despair of conveying it."

He did not, however, despair of attempting it, and was some minutes about the work. Jane bore it with the sweetness she brought to everything, including bores; and I loved her for it, and did not envy her, and drew Charlotte off before I could be caught laughing at my own kin.

Then Mr. Bingley came in, and the chimney-piece ceased to matter, though nobody yet knew it.

He was everything the neighbourhood had ordered and a degree warmer than it had dared hope — easy, open, quick to be pleased, the kind of young man who enters a strange room as though it has been got up entirely for his enjoyment and is delighted to find his friends already in it. He was introduced down the line of us, declared he had never met with pleasanter people or prettier girls in his life, and was believed, because he so plainly believed it himself. He danced every dance. And within the half-hour he had found Jane, and after that he found very little else.

I watched it happen from one dance away: a beloved sister and a likeable stranger discovering one another in public, each convinced they were the soul of discretion. He brought her lemonade she had not asked for — the second man that evening to bring her a drink unasked, and the first to be thanked with a blush. He stood up with her twice, which in Meryton was very nearly a banns-reading. My mother watched the same scene from across the room, and I saw the very moment her eye left Jane and travelled to Mr. Collins, and from Mr. Collins to me; and I understood that I had just been promoted in the order of business.

For the present, however, I was occupied with Mr. Bingley's friend.

He had come in at Mr. Bingley's shoulder and had not warmed by a single degree in the hour since. Mr. Darcy was the taller man and the handsomer, with a keen aquiline face and piercing blue eyes; he had ten thousand a year to Bingley's five; and the room had established all of this and then fallen out of love with him inside ten minutes, on the grounds that he would not dance, would not be pleased, and looked at Meryton as a man looks at weather he must presently go out into. I had given him no great share of my attention once it was clear he considered himself above his company. I record this so that what follows may be understood to have been entirely his own doing.

I was resting between dances, half hidden by the angle of a pillar. The wall of seated women lay in my view — the chaperones, the visiting aunts, the ladies past dancing — and among them a stranger I took for someone's formidable relation up from the country, a widow by her dress, who held her chair as though the room had been set out around it and watched the dancers with an openness no woman of the gentry is taught to allow herself, keeping one face and then another past the moment courtesy returns a look to its owner. Mr. Bingley had come up to his friend a few feet from me, flushed from the dance and bent on sharing his good fortune.

"Come, Darcy. I must have you dance. I hate to see you standing about by yourself in this stupid manner."

"You know how I detest it, unless I am acquainted with my partner."

"I would not be so fastidious as you are for a kingdom! Upon my honour, I never met with so many pleasant girls in my life as I have this evening — and several of them uncommonly pretty."

"You have been dancing with the only handsome girl in the room."

"She is the most beautiful creature I ever beheld! But there is one of her sisters sitting down just behind you, who is very pretty, and I dare say very agreeable. Do let me ask my partner to introduce you."

Mr. Darcy looked at me. It was a brief but unhurried look. I have been looked at a great many ways in my life, but never before, that I could remember, as a question someone was working out.

"I think not," he said. "I cannot suppose Miss Elizabeth Bennet would be tolerable company. Her father I take to be a gentleman of a reclusive type, who cannot be bothered with social events. And her mother is clearly the spoiled and ignorant younger daughter of someone in trade. A country attorney, I would guess."

He said it quietly, and not unkindly, and that was the whole of the trouble. There was no spite in it. He was not paying me out for a slight, nor jabbing at his friend for dragging him to the ball. He had looked at me, read off what I came from as another man might read a signpost, and concluded that the destination of our acquaintance would not be worth the journey. And in his guesses as to my family he was unfortunately correct. My father did despise the assembly and was at home with his books. My mother was the younger daughter of a Meryton attorney and was, that very evening and at some volume, both of the other things he had named her.

I had expected, if ever I were to be slighted by such a man, to be told I was plain. Every woman keeps an answer ready for that, and a witty one keeps three. I had no answer ready for being read correctly and found not worth the reading; the sting of it had an edge I had not met before, and I disliked him from that moment with an interest I should have found harder to account for than I cared to try. I gave my attention back to the room and resolved to think no more of him — a resolution I kept for the better part of an hour.

What I did with the hour was tell the story. I told it as a joke against a proud man — the gentleman from town who could name your grandfather's profession at twenty paces and found nothing in the room worth standing up with — and it earned the laugh it was built for, every time, which was the only shape I could bear to give it. Charlotte heard the performance twice before she had it from me plainly, behind the pillar, with the laugh left off.

She did not look surprised.

"He is right about your father, you know," she said.

"Charlotte."

"And about your mother at these things. You have said as much yourself, and worse."

"When I say it, it is filial honesty. When he says it, it is ten thousand a year being clever at a country assembly."

"A man who says only true things and none of them kind is a tiresome guest. I grant you that. But I would rather sit by a man who sees clearly and holds his tongue half the time than by one who flatters and sees nothing at all. You will meet a great many more of the second kind than the first." She took my arm. "Now stop attending to the one man in the room who will not dance with you, and come and watch your sister fall in love. It is by far the better entertainment."

It was, and we watched it together until the musicians were sent home.

The carriage afterward held the seven of us and my mother's happiness, which wanted the greater room. Twice, Jane — he had stood up with her twice, and his sisters so elegant, and five thousand a year, and her father should hear every word of it that night whether he would or no. Jane ventured that Mr. Bingley was just what a young man ought to be, and blushed in the dark where she thought it could not be seen. Mr. Collins pronounced the evening a credit to the neighbourhood, though inferior, he must in honesty observe, to the assemblies at Rosings; that her ladyship attended no assemblies did not appear to weaken the comparison for him.

And then my mother fell silent for the length of a mile, which was so far against her custom that I looked over. She was studying Mr. Collins. Then she turned and looked at me down the length of the carriage, the way she looked at a room before she rearranged the furniture in it.

I knew that look of old, and I knew there was no arguing with what came behind it.

But that kept until morning.

Fanficcing With Claude: A Curious Case, Chapter 1 (J. H.W.)

The Curious Case of the Kentish Clergyman is a Pride and Prejudice mystery, serialized here in chapters. This opening chapter is presented in the voice of Dr. John H. Watson; the manuscript that follows is narrated throughout by Elizabeth Bennet Darcy.

"John," said my wife one evening last spring, looking up from a litter of papers that had colonised the whole of the dining table, "what was your grandmother Watson's name before she married?"

I considered the question over my pipe and was obliged to confess I had no idea.

"Your great-grandmother, then."

"My dear Mary, I could not swear to my grandmother's Christian name without notice. I am a doctor and a biographer. I leave the begats to the clergy."

She made a note and went back to her papers, and I thought no more of it. Mary had taken up the study of her own family that winter, in the patient way that women of her temper take up such things, with a deal of correspondence and a great many afternoons given over to parish registers. She had run her own people back as far as the registers would carry her, found them respectable and unremarkable in equal measure, and turned, for want of fresh quarry, to mine.

My people are north-country, and the north does not throw things away: within the fortnight a cousin of mine near Scarborough had sent down two hampers of family papers that nobody had opened since the Regency. Mary worked through them with her registers at her elbow. Somewhere in the second hamper was a journal, kept by some gentleman of the family in a hand like a cavalry charge; she gave an evening to it, reported that it concerned chiefly partridges, and set it aside in favour of the parish registers, which at least were legible. For three weeks the dining table was lost to us. Then one evening she set a single sheet beside my plate and stood watching me with a look of barely suppressed glee.

"Read it through twice," she said. "You will want to."

The line she had traced was mine, not hers; and it ran back, through a marriage in the early part of the century, to a Hertfordshire family of small fortune and considerable wit, and from there, by a turning I shall set out in its proper place, into the maternal ancestry of the two men I knew best in the world.

I read it through twice. Then I put on my coat and went to Baker Street.

Holmes heard me out without interruption, which was itself remarkable. When I had done he sat a moment with his fingertips together in the old attitude.

"You will want my brother," he said. "Mycroft has had the documents for some years."

"You knew of this?"

"I knew that there were papers in the family. Mycroft keeps such things." He reached for his pipe. "Go to the Diogenes, Watson. He will receive you, which you may take as the measure of how little the matter excites him."

I had my hand on the door when he spoke again.

"You understand that I am pleased to own you for a cousin," he said, without looking up from the pipe. "But you must not flatter yourself that the discovery raises you in my estimation. A man could not have been more valuable to me than you have already contrived to be, and the matter was settled long before our kinship was discovered." He struck a match. "Give my regards to Mycroft. He will not return them, but the form should be observed."

It is the nearest thing to a sentiment I ever had from him, and he buried it, as he buried all such things, under a remark about something else. I went down the stairs better pleased than the words alone would account for.

Mycroft Holmes received me in the Stranger's Room of the Diogenes Club the following afternoon, immense and immovable, and confirmed the whole of it before I had got my hat off. "Sit down, Doctor. Sherlock wired me this morning. You will want the manuscript."

"You have known of this — how long?"

"The better part of ten years."

"And it did not strike you as worth mentioning?"

"It struck me as a fact." He looked at me the way he looks at a column of figures that has added up correctly. "An interesting fact. I considered whether it bore upon anything, concluded that it did not, and gave my attention to matters that did. Had the connexion ever become relevant to any business in hand, you would have heard of it within the hour."

"Relevant to business," I said. "My kinship by blood to you and your brother?"

"Just so."

I have known few men who could deliver so extraordinary a thing so flatly, and I did not try to make him feel it more than he did. One does not improve Mycroft by prodding him.

He fetched the manuscript himself, trusting it to no club servant. It was a great square parcel, wrapped against the dust, heavier than it looked.

"What is it?" I asked. "Mary's paper goes no further than the names."

"An account of certain events in Hertfordshire and Kent, a matter of eighty years ago, set down some while afterward by the lady to whom they occurred. She had it privately circulated among the family. I have read it once." He pushed the club's ledger across for my signature. "I shall tell you nothing else about it, and within the week you will thank me for that."

"Is it so dull?"

"It is the other thing," said Mycroft, and rang for my coat.

It was long, and I read it through twice before I understood why I could not put it down. I had gone to it as a curiosity of the blood: a chance to see, as it were, the rough ore from which two such singular intelligences had been refined. I found an account, written by a lady of uncommon penetration, of the man she married; and in that man I met, set down plainly for the first time, a temper I had been studying at close quarters for the better part of twenty years without ever quite getting the measure of it.

The lady, whom I shall call Elizabeth Darcy, was the keenest observer I have encountered on the page, and she missed very little. But the gift the manuscript explained to me was her husband's. In her account of Mr. Darcy I came at last upon the thing that years of watching Sherlock Holmes light a pipe and pronounce upon a stranger's regiment, his griefs, and his bootmaker had never made clear to me: what such a faculty costs the man who carries it, and what it asks of those obliged to live within range of it. Elizabeth Darcy reveals her husband to us. Her husband, in turn, has made my friend legible to me at last. The debt runs in that direction, and I am content to leave it there.

There is one further figure in these pages whom I cannot pass without a word, though I shall be brief, for the comparison does no kindness to anyone. The lady's father, a gentleman of wit and indolence in equal measure, sits among his books while the affairs of his house go forward without his hand. He sees everything and stirs for nothing. I have sat in the Stranger's Room of the Diogenes Club and watched the same economy of effort in a far greater mind, applied to far greater questions, and arriving too often at the same repose. I am fond of Mycroft Holmes. I will say no more than that.

One smaller irony I set down once and then leave alone: that it should fall to me, descended through the elder and gentler of the two sisters, to lay the younger sister's manuscript before the public. Elizabeth Darcy would, I think, have been amused. She was amused by most things, including herself, which is among the reasons one trusts her.

It was Mary who closed the circle. On the evening I finished the manuscript the second time, I told her something of what it contained; and she sat very still through the better part of it, and then went out of the room without a word, and came back carrying the journal with the unfortunate handwriting.

"John," she said. "The partridge gentleman was called Charles Bingley."

We read it together that night, she deciphering and I attending, until the candles wanted replacing. The diarist found in the second hamper was the amiable gentleman mentioned in these pages: the friend at Mr. Darcy's elbow, the husband of the elder sister, my own great-grandfather. He kept his cheerful, blotted, headlong record at the same time that the lady of this manuscript was watching everything he missed.

I will be honest about what I found in it, since the reader will discover it in any case. Mr. Bingley saw a great deal and understood very little of it, and set the whole down with perfect fidelity and no suspicion of what he carried. He records that his friend was grave, and gives three sentences to the covey. He is never once ahead of events. He is kind about everyone, including one or two persons about whom kindness was an error of some magnitude. And I read him with a discomfort that took me several entries to place, until Mary placed it for me by laughing at something I had not thought was a joke. I have passed my life at the elbow of a man who reads a stranger's history in his watch-chain, recording faithfully what I saw, and understanding it afterward, when it was explained to me. I know the office. It appears to be hereditary.

Three practical matters, and I have done.

First, as to discretion. The events the manuscript relates were grave, and some of those concerned left descendants who do not deserve to inherit the knowledge of them. I have altered the names of the guilty and of their nearest kin, and a handful of places besides. I have given away nothing of the resolution, and the reader who hopes I will spare him the lady's own unfolding of the business will be disappointed, and rightly. It is her story. She tells it in her own order.

Second, as to her manner of telling it. Elizabeth Darcy wrote these pages a great many years after the events they describe, from the settled vantage of a long marriage and a changed world. She knew, as she wrote, how every doubt resolved and every danger ended, and she declines, almost entirely, to make use of that knowledge. She keeps herself inside the season she is describing, with every error live and unredeemed, and she does not reach back from safety to comfort her younger self or to warn the reader. It is a discipline I have rarely seen sustained for ten pages together, and she sustains it for four hundred. I have tried to honour it by keeping out of her way.

Third, as to the journal. The lady's account cannot follow the gentlemen into the gun-room, onto the London road, behind the doors where her husband's part of the business was done. At those few points where her page cannot see, I have set in an entry of Mr. Bingley's in its proper place in the chronology. I have corrected nothing beyond what legibility demanded. The hand is dreadful and the spelling original, and Mary, who transcribed the entries, wishes it recorded that she has earned her place on this title page twice over. The reader will be ahead of the diarist on every page of his that follows, which is as it should be. He was ahead of nobody in his life, and was the better loved for it. The reader will always know whose page he is on.

When I had finished the manuscript the first time, I sent a note round to the Diogenes conceding that Mycroft had been right to tell me nothing. His reply was on my breakfast table by nine o'clock: "Of course. You now understand why I read it only once."

I have thought about that sentence a good deal since. The reader who finishes these pages will know what he meant by it — and will know, too, why a man who forgets nothing chose, in this one case, never to look again into the mirror it provided him, reflecting a man much like himself, and another man much like his brother, in the long-ago days of the Prince Regent.

— J. H. W.