The Novels of Marie Belloc Lowndes: The Jane Austen Fanfics

(Note: As previously indicated, the Lowndes books I have read are mostly available on Gutenberg and/or Amazon. In past reviews of early 20th century books, I have not made any effort to offer content warnings, on the assumption that anybody reading these reviews knows better than to expect present-day attitudes on certain topics from books of this timeframe. I am continuing with that assumption here.)

“Fanfics” is maybe a strong word for it; “remixes” or “riffs” might be better. But there are definitely places where you can see kind of a Jane Austen strain in the Lowndes novels, both in their interest in the social order and their microscopically close study of the characters’ emotions, even though Lowndes is not remotely in Austen’s league as a writer. The title character in Heart of Penelope has something of an Elizabeth Bennet vibe – plus nicer parents and more money and a hundred years of progress in the status of women, but minus Mr. Darcy. The title character in Jane Oglander is a bit like the “people-pleaser” interpretations of Jane Bennet, although the situation she’s in during the later stages of the novel would look more familiar to Elinor Dashwood or Fanny Price.

The novels I discuss below have a stronger Jane Austen angle than usual; two of them namecheck Austen characters and one recognizably reworks the Henry Crawford subplot from Mansfield Park.

Continue reading “The Novels of Marie Belloc Lowndes: The Jane Austen Fanfics”

The Novels of Marie Belloc Lowndes: The Ones That End Where Agatha Christie Begins

(Note: As previously indicated, the Lowndes books I have read are mostly available on Gutenberg and/or Amazon. In past reviews of early 20th century books, I have not made any effort to offer content warnings, on the assumption that anybody reading these reviews knows better than to expect present-day attitudes on certain topics from books of this timeframe. I am continuing with that assumption here.)

Alot of Agatha Christie’s novels feel like we’re on the outside of some messy domestic situation, looking in at the situation shortly before and after it turns violent. If you ever wondered what seeing the inside of those situations would be like, you’re in luck! Marie Belloc Lowndes wrote lots of those. The characterization is a mile wide and an inch deep, and the situations tend to repeat themselves, but to me, there’s something insistent and weirdly compelling about the way Lowndes shows the reader every component in these emotional powder kegs. As a bonus, you get a good look at the kind of expectations authors like Agatha Christie set out to subvert, because the whodunnit components of these mysteries tend to be pretty banal.

Continue reading “The Novels of Marie Belloc Lowndes: The Ones That End Where Agatha Christie Begins”

The Novels of Marie Belloc Lowndes: Hercule Popeau and Various Innocents Abroad

(Note: As previously indicated, the Lowndes books I have read are mostly available on Gutenberg and/or Amazon. In past reviews of early 20th century books, I have not made any effort to offer content warnings, on the assumption that anybody reading these reviews knows better than to expect present-day attitudes on certain topics from books of this timeframe. I am continuing with that assumption here.)

The second-most famous thing Lowndes did, (the most famous being her novel The Lodger), was to write a novel called The Lonely House, in which a sheltered, financially prosperous young Englishwoman fetches up in Monaco, only to be caught up in a love triangle and menaced by people who are after her money, although she has trouble grasping their bad intentions.

Continue reading “The Novels of Marie Belloc Lowndes: Hercule Popeau and Various Innocents Abroad”

The Novels of Marie Belloc Lowndes: The Lodger

There’s a famous quote by Alfred Hitchcock, about how (paraphrasing) a bomb going off in a scene with no buildup is surprise, while watching the buildup to a bomb going off, knowing there is a bomb about to go off, is suspense. I’ve been reading a bunch of Marie Belloc Lowndes lately, and it seems safe to say that Hilaire Belloc’s sister was a suspense writer, when she wasn’t writing flat-out soap opera. Her best-known novel is The Lodger,(1) which is available for free on Gutenberg or very cheaply on Amazon (basically you’re paying to spare yourself the hassle of getting the book into kindle by yourself).

Essentially, this is the story of Mr. and Mrs. Bunting,(2) a former butler and his very prim second wife, who have gone into business for themselves, subletting rooms in their rental house with the understanding that they will feed the lodgers and clean up after them etc. Business has been bad, and the husband, a true-crime buff, has been distracting himself by following the exploits of a Ripper-like serial killer called the Avenger, who seems to specialize in killing formerly respectable women who’ve gone off the skids due to alcoholism(3). A young policeman acquaintance keeps Mr. Bunting supplied with all the latest news on the case, including some tidbits that he really should keep to himself. By the merest of accidents, Mrs. Bunting ends up being the one who answers the door when a gaunt, nervous gentleman shows up asking for lodgings.

Continue reading “The Novels of Marie Belloc Lowndes: The Lodger”